The General Synod of the Church of England began its next five-year session (‘quinquennium’) yesterday (my fourth, and likely my last), and given the fractious debates that marked the last five years, the question of unity was never far away.
The prayer of Jesus in John 17 was in the background of the Archbishop of Canterbury’s presidential address to General Synod. Sarah Mullally reminded members that Jesus prayed for our unity before he went to the cross, and went on, ‘He did not pray for us to all agree about everything—though he did pray that we would be one’. There is much in the address to welcome, and I will come back to it.
If I was given sixpence every time I heard someone quote John 17.21, ‘…that they might be one…’, then I’d have a lot of change that I wouldn’t know what to do with. The phrase became something like the motto of the twentieth-century ecumenical movement, and in 1995 John Paul II took the title of his encyclical on Christian unity, Ut Unum Sint, from the Latin of this verse. It is commonly suggested that, in this, Jesus’ ‘high priestly prayer’, we see his last desire expressed to his heavenly Father, and that desire is for his people to have visible unity.
We must therefore take this seriously, and make it a priority above other issues since, after all, it was so important to Jesus that it formed his final wish. But does John 17 support the distinction between agreement and oneness in the way that Sarah Mullally suggested?
It is worth looking at the prayer a little more closely, and putting it in its context both in John’s gospel and amongst the gospels as a whole. The prayer forms the climax of the Last Supper discourse in John—but of course John himself mentions no supper, but instead focusses on the washing of the disciples’ feet by Jesus. This reminds us that we need to read John in one hand with the synoptics, and particularly Mark, in the other; the two fill out each other and give each other context. So we read that, after this prayer of John 17, Jesus goes out [to Gethsemane] in John 18.1, but we need to turn to Mark 14.32 to know the name of the place and what happens there.
It is also worth noting from the outset that the longer form of Jesus’ speech in John is not, in itself, a reason to treat the synoptics as more historical, and John more of a theological construction of what Jesus said. Even the speeches in John are relatively short, and all the teaching of Jesus recorded in the synoptics would take mere hours to recite, so we must treat them as (quite possibly reliable) summaries of longer and more extensive teaching.
Turning to the prayer itself, we find many of the earlier themes and ideas in John drawn together. First, we meet the notions of ‘hour’ and ‘glory’; John has from the beginning been interested in days and hours, and in Cana Jesus tells Mary that ‘my hour has not yet come’ (John 2.4) and yet, in the miracle and in anticipation of what is to follow here, ‘Jesus did the first of his signs…and revealed his glory’ (John 2.11). Now he can say, ‘Father, the hour has come; glorify your Son’ (John 17.1), and the glory he asks for is the glory he had with the Father before the world existed (John 17.5).
Then we have the interrelated ideas of life and truth. Eternal life is to know the true God (John 17.3), whom Jesus alone reveals. In the prologue in John 1, we have already been introduced to the light who was life for the world from the beginning of creation. And that light is constantly linked with testimony—of John, of Jesus’ disciples, and of Jesus himself. The idea of the work of the Son being aligned with the work of the Father takes us back to the idea that ‘my Father is always working’ in John 5.17 and that the work demanded of us is faith—believing in what Jesus teaches (John 6.29).
The distinction of the disciples from the world touches on John’s ambiguous theology of ‘world’—it is the object of God’s love (John 3.16) but is also opposed to God and the things of God (John 15.18), so that (paradoxically) to love the world is to hate God (1 John 2.15). This contrast between the disciples and the world reflects Jesus’ own relationship with the world (John 17.16); though the world ‘came into being through him, it did not know him’ (John 1.10) and ‘his own people [both the Jews and all humanity] did not receive him’ (John 1.11). His own ministry and kingdom do not have their origin in the world—that is the real meaning of Jesus’ statement to Pilate in John 18.36, often mistranslated as ‘of this world’ rather than ‘from (ek) this world’, as if the kingdom did not have an impact on earthly structures of power.
Even so, Jesus does not ask the Father to take his disciples out of the world (John 17.15). The question of where Jesus ‘remains’ or stays or abides has been of interest from the disciples’ first encounter, when they ask, ‘Rabbi, where are you staying/abiding?’ (John 1.38). We now learn that Jesus abides in the Father, and we need to abide in him, and that he will no longer abide in this world but is going to the Father. (This idea of movement from the Father’s side, down to the incarnation, and up again back to the Father is neither late nor uniquely Johannine, since we find the same movement in Phil 2.5–11 and in 2 Cor 8.9.)
Now we begin to approach the heart of the prayer, where the statement about unity comes. Jesus’ key concern is for the protection of the disciples in the midst of the world in which they remain but to which they do not belong. ‘Holy Father, keep them in your name’ (John 17.11)—and it is striking that the first mention of unity in the prayer comes here, as the purpose of this keeping, ‘so that they may be one, as we are one’. Unity is first of all something the Father gives as he keeps his people, not something they achieve. Then comes the second request, ‘Make them holy in the truth; your word is truth’ (John 17.17).
The language of truth goes to the heart of a key theme in John; as Andrew Lincoln and Mark Stibbe have pointed out, the whole of John can be understood as a form of trial narrative, with witnesses called to testify to the truth of Jesus’ claims and identity, and the Father even called to the witness stand (John 8.18). That is why the conflict is so sharp with the ‘leaders of the Jews’ in chapters 5 to 8, because they are the prosecuting counsel, and that is why John’s account of the crucifixion naturally includes the extended dialogue with Pilate (conveyed to us by one of the servants there) which is not included in the synoptics.
‘Your word’ here cannot refer to Jesus himself, even within the ‘logos’ Christology of John, not least because Jesus has already talked of the cleansing and sanctifying work of his words, that is, his teaching of truth, in relation to abiding in the vine (John 15.3). To be holy involves remaining in the person and work of Jesus, and remaining in his teaching which reveals the truth about us, God and the world. And this holiness is for the sake of testimony, since Jesus sends them into the world as the Father sent him, and sanctifies himself for their sake ‘so that they too may be made holy in truth’ (John 17.18–19).
It is into this context that Jesus then longs for the unity of his people. And we should notice whom he is praying for. ‘I ask not only on behalf of these, but also on behalf of those who will believe in me through their word’ (John 17.20). Those who come later are joined to the first disciples through the apostolic testimony, so the unity they share is unity with that word, not apart from it. Ernst Käsemann made this point forcefully in his classic study of John 17, The Testament of Jesus, arguing that for John the unity of the church is grounded in the word Jesus has given and cannot be separated from it.
The parallel with the unity between Jesus and the Father cannot be exact, not least with the hindsight we have following the Nicene expressions of our understanding of the Trinity. But John has already shown us what this oneness looks like. When Jesus says ‘I and the Father are one’ (John 10.30), the word is neuter (hen, ‘one thing’) and not masculine, and the context is the shared action of Father and Son in keeping the sheep safe. The Son does nothing on his own, but only what he sees the Father doing (John 5.19); he seeks not his own will but the will of the one who sent him (John 5.30).
So it is about the unity of commitment, will and understanding; just as Jesus does the will and work of the Father, and just as the Father’s testimony is completely unified with the testimony of Jesus, so his disciples are to have that one commitment to true testimony which reveals the truth of God—and which will then lead many who have not themselves been witnesses of Jesus also to believe (John 20.31). And it is a unity with God before it is a unity with one another, since they are to be one ‘in us’ (en hēmin, John 17.21).
We need to take seriously the purpose of this unity, which the prayer spells out twice. They are to be one ‘so that the world may believe that you sent me’ (John 17.21), and ‘so that the world may know that you sent me and have loved them even as you loved me’ (John 17.23). Those who quote this verse are quite right that the unity Jesus prays for has a missional purpose. But what kind of unity will persuade the world of this? The world is not being invited to admire an institution that manages to hold together, but to believe something true, that the Father has sent the Son. A unity can bear witness to that truth only if it is a unity in that truth. There is no sense here that the unity of the believers in and of itself, disconnected from the truth, plays any role in the conviction of the world.
Two further phrases point the same way. ‘The glory that you have given me I have given them, so that they may be one, as we are one’ (John 17.22); unity depends on a gift, and in John ‘glory’ is the revelation of who God is in Jesus. And Jesus prays that they may be ‘completely one’, literally ‘perfected into one’ (teteleiōmenoi eis hen, John 17.23). The perfect passive participle describes something God does and brings to completion, and so looks forward as well as back. The unity of Jesus’ people is not first of all a matter of our management.
Some will respond that the emphasis here falls on love, and so it does. The world is to know that the Father has loved the disciples as he loved the Son (John 17.23), and the prayer ends with Jesus’ longing ‘that the love with which you have loved me may be in them, and I in them’ (John 17.26). This echoes the new commandment, ‘By this everyone will know that you are my disciples, if you have love for one another’ (John 13.35). But in John love and truth are never set against each other. Love for Jesus is shown in keeping his commandments (John 14.15) and his word (John 14.23), and the elder writes to those he loves ‘in truth’, rejoicing to find them ‘walking in the truth’ (2 John 1–4). To appeal to love as a reason to set truth aside is to pull apart what John holds together.
Jesus finishes the prayer with an inclusio return to the theme of glory (John 17.24), but does so with a unique address to God as ‘righteous Father’ (John 17.25)—only the third time John uses the term ‘righteous’ (after John 5.30 and John 7.24) and the only time in the New Testament that God is described in this way. It fits the trial setting of the whole gospel; the world has not known the Father, but Jesus has, and his disciples have come to know that the Father sent him, and the righteous Father is the judge who will vindicate their testimony.
So Jesus’ prayer for unity is tightly bound with concerns for the truth, for holiness, for the distinctive testimony of his people over against the world to which they do not belong, leading to the revelation of the glory of God and by which, through faithful testimony, many in the world will come to believe that Jesus is the only true revelation of the Father who loves them and draws them to himself.
The Spirit is not named in John 17, but the farewell discourse has already told us how this unity in the truth will be sustained once Jesus has gone. The Spirit is the ‘Spirit of truth’ (John 14.17; John 15.26), who will guide the disciples into all the truth, taking what belongs to Jesus and declaring it to them (John 16.13–15). The Spirit testifies about Jesus, and the disciples testify alongside him (John 15.26–27), so that it is the Spirit who holds Jesus’ people together in the truth.
And of course we find very similar inter-relationships between these concerns elsewhere. In the oft-cited example of the Council of Acts 15, it is striking that the understanding of the new experience of seeing the Spirit poured out on the Gentiles (Acts 15.8) is interpreted by means of discerning God’s purposes in Scripture (Acts 15.15–18, citing Amos 9.11–12), and (most notably for us) is then recognised by all of God’s people in unanimity (Acts 15.25), so that they can say ‘it seemed good to the Holy Spirit and to us’ (Acts 15.28).
The accord with Scripture and the unified reception by the people both attest to the truth of the interpretation. And the agreement they reached concerned both belief and behaviour, since the letter to the Gentile churches set out how they were to live (Acts 15.20; Acts 15.29). Yet Luke does not paint an idealised picture. Within a few verses Paul and Barnabas part company after a sharp disagreement over whether to take John Mark with them (Acts 15.39). The church could be of one mind on the question that touched the gospel, and still disagree, even painfully, on a matter that did not.
And all this brings us back to the Archbishop’s address. Much of what she said about unity is welcome. She is right that unity is a gift of God, received through grace and faith, and not something we manufacture; John 17 bears that out, since the Father keeps his people in his name so that they may be one (John 17.11), and Jesus gives them his glory for the same purpose (John 17.22). She is right, too, that the way Christians handle disagreement is part of our witness. And she is right that Jesus did not pray that we would agree about everything; Paul and Barnabas did not, and the church survived it.
But the contrast between agreeing and being one is not one that John 17 allows us to draw so easily. The disciples for whom Jesus prays are those who ‘have kept your word’ (John 17.6), who have received the words the Father gave him and ‘have believed that you sent me’ (John 17.8), and those who come after them believe ‘through their word’ (John 17.20). The faith through which unity is given always has content in John; it is believing that something is true. And the holiness Jesus prays for takes shape in how we live, since those who love him keep his commandments (John 14.15).
So the oneness of John 17 is a unity in belief and in behaviour, held together in love. That does not mean agreeing about everything, but it does mean agreeing about some things—and the question the Church of England has not yet settled is which things those are. Acts 15 gives us a pointer, since the church there reached one mind on both what God had done and how believers should then live.
I doubt that the Archbishop would want to say that unity has no connection with what we believe or how we live. But language that sets oneness against agreement, without saying where agreement matters, is in danger of being heard that way. And it leaves Synod without the very help it most needs from this passage. Earlier in the ‘farewell discourse’, Jesus says:
As the Father has loved me, so have I loved you. Now remain in my love. 10 If you keep my commands, you will remain in my love, just as I have kept my Father’s commands and remain in his love…You are my friends if you do what I command. (John 15.9-10, 14)
Love, friendship, intimacy, and obedience belong together, and in the teaching of Jesus, and in our lives as his followers, these cannot be separated.
Perhaps this is an object lesson in the dangers of the ‘memory verse’ approach to reading Scripture, by which we isolate one phrase from its immediate and wider context, and so lose important elements which it needs in order to be understood properly.
The Church of England needs to hold together unity with obedience, the friendship of Jesus with a readiness to obey his commands, if our unity is to actually endure the challenges of the next five years.









as Andrew Lincoln and Mark Stibbe have pointed out, the whole of John can be understood as a form of trial narrative, with witnesses called to testify to the truth of Jesus’ claims and identity, and the Father even called to the witness stand
That’s interesting. It applies too to the Book of Job, in which Job gets out of his fatalistic desperation by in effect putting a lawsuit on God, since in law you can cross-examine your opponent, who loses if he stays silent. Putting God in the dock is not a new idea. It was Eliphaz’s bad suggestion (Job 5:8), but Job believes (rightly) that a man cannot win against God (9:2-3), and he (wrongly) does not trust God enough to hear him out (9:14-17), saying that God would find him guilty whatever (9:20). Unlike Bildad (8:3), Job does not believe that God, as one party and also judge, would be impartial (9:30-31). Only in a neutral court could Job state himself without fear (9:35-10:1), but no court is above God, so Job does not wish to resort to law (9:28). He wants a mediator (9:33-34) and is even confident that one exists (16:19-21). He is goaded by his friends’ insistence that some sin of his must be the cause, which God should explain. According to an American lawyer, Edward L. Greenstein, Chapter 13 consists largely of legal formalities of the era. Later, with God still silent, Job swears his innocence (chs. 29-31). He rests his case at 31:35. Now it is up to God to respond or, in theory, lose.
Job was wise to be scared to sue God. It is unwise for the clay to talk back to the potter (Isaiah 29:16, 45:9). “Who are you to talk back to God?” (Romans 9:20); “Do not put Yahweh your God to the test” (Deut 6:16). God does respond but, instead of answering Job’s question, cross-examines him – not about Job’s sin, which he was expecting to hear about, but about his ignorance and presumption. God first shows Job that he knows nothing of the material world (38:1-35, a fine response today to cocky atheists), then shows Job that he knows nothing of the animal world (38:39 – 41:34). God knows about them, for He made them. Job realises that he knows little even of basic aspects of physics and biology, let alone moral mysteries. Jesus said that a flower exceeded all of King Solomon’s finery (Matt 6:28-30). The way to navigate life is to drop legalism and trust God. Suing God is perhaps the most futile thing a man can attempt. Job takes the point – he admits his incapacity to reply at 40:5-6, but God continues by issuing a challenge to Job to justify himself (40:14), until finally Job repents (‘in dust and ashes,’ 42:6). God then restores Job, both spiritually and materially.
the oneness of John 17 is a unity in belief and in behaviour, held together in love. That does not mean agreeing about everything, but it does mean agreeing about some things—and the question the Church of England has not yet settled is which things those are.
It did know, but it failed to expel heretics in the matter of sexual ethics, who inevitably set up their own party within the Church of England, causing disunity. There will not be unity again until they are expelled.
The Church of England is established church, by definition therefore it can’t expel anyone who wishes to be a member of it. Even convicted criminals of serious offences, albeit obviously they can’t be clergy or bishops
Do you mean on an individual basis?
There have been numerous expulsions and ejections from the church of England in its history.
Indeed there was an event called ‘The Great Ejection’ in 1662. I believe the Unitarians were later driven out in the 1770s and a number of Ritualist clergy were deprived (and even imprisoned) in the 1870s.
Subscription to the articles of Religion is no longer required but even in our day anyone who refused, for instance, to receive baptism would be excluded from our communion.
Yes but that was in the time when denying the Trinity as the Unitarians did was a criminal offence. Place of Roman Catholic worship could only start to be registered again from the mid nineteenth century. You can also worship without receiving communion
“You can also worship without receiving communion.”
Indeed you can worship, but can you be ‘in communion’ without being baptised?
As I understand you can not and are not in communion (at least with the Church of England) if you remain unbaptised.
But the Act of Uniformity threw out the true believers, the honest men who refused to tell the lie that the Articles, Prayer Book and Ordinal contained nothing contrary to the Woed of God!
The Acts of Uniformity established the Book of Common Prayer as the single, unified form of worship in England to be used by the Church of England. If you don’t even agree with the contents of the Book of Common Prayer then what on earth are you doing in the Church of England anyway? There are plenty of other nonconformist Baptist or Pentecostal churches you can join anyway
There weren’t in 1662. John Bunyan wrote the best-loed Christain book other than the Bible while in prison for unlicensed preaching under that raft of laws.
John Bunyan was a member of a Bedford Free Church, he was not really an Anglican even in the terms of those times. We are also not in 1662, everyone in the UK is free to be a member of whatever church they choose
Are you ducking the issue or unaware that you HAD to worship in the CoE after the Clarendon code went through, including the Act of Uniformity?
The Church of England was the sole form of public worship, though nonconformists could meet in groups of four or five or less within a household. Bunyan as I said was not an Anglican but a member of a Free Church and if you don’t accept the authority of the BCP as the original prayer book for the C of E as I also said you should not be in the Church of England
Right, you are ducking the issue. The CoE was content to persecute other Christians. Which then were more Christian?
Why do we assume we know the details of the trial before Pilate “through a servant” since Christ Himself could have revealed them to John after His resurrection?
Quite!
I suppose, but would the risen Jesus have spent his time telling them who said what to whom at his trial? Might have had better things to do. I think it is more likely a witness.
Peter
“would the risen Jesus have spent his time telling them who said what to whom at his trial?”
I’d have thought yes – the stuff raised in and by the trial (indeed trials, not just before Pilate) is of great importance, particularly to the relationship of the Church to the surrounding world.
It intrigues me that the Holy Spirit does not get a mention in John 17 yet He will be responsible for making the oneness happen! I see it as an organic oneness created by love as Paul put it in Ephesians: ‘bearing with one another in love, endeavouring to keep the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace’. Or in another form of words in Colossians: ‘put on love which is the bond of perfection and let the peace of God rule in your hearts’.
Surely this was expressed evidently after the Spirit was given when: ‘those who believed were of one heart and soul … they had all things in common’. This was visible organic love following the lead of the Spirit into unity. And, of course, when Ananias and Sapphira broke that bond of trust they had “lied to the Holy Spirit”. It is working with the Holy Spirit which creates the unity of love. It should go without saying that the Holy Spirit produces unity in Holiness which is both what we believe and how we share our lives together.
Increasingly I am becoming aware of the – at best shallow – and – at worst -misleading references to Scripture by senior church leaders in their speeches and writings. In many cases these seek to match the message they wish to deliver, often in the context of their efforts to be acceptable to the majority, rather than being faithful to the true meaning of the Scriptures themselves.
Our church is currently looking at the curate’s egg “Pilgrim Series”, of which Archbishop Stephen Cottrell is one of the main authors. Although just about “good in parts”, the authors often use a verse from Scripture to match their theme, but examination of the verse’s surrounding passage shows a completely different context to that said theme.
Is this an indication of how little in depth Biblical and theological knowledge our church leaders have, something Ian has alluded to in the past, I think?
What will unify the CofE?
I suggest a commitment of all Anglicans to believe and preach Articles 9 and 17 on Original Sin and Predestination to Life.
Anthony your encapsulation of the life of Job
Is superb,and does focus our minds on our current Question: The Battle of the Theologies.
Both sides are convinced that their theology is
Fundamental; we lean towards Job’s dilemma
because we know from the beginning that God
admires him and holds him up as an example of
God’s pleasure.
Despite his great theological struggles “within and without”; aka Paul,
God does not vindicate him until much later.
As you properly note God addresses not his certainties but his ignorance.
Which profoundly impacts Job’s estimation of things,
God appoints him as priest to his friends and prayed/interceded for them, they in turn were directed to this priest whom He vindicated as speaking the truth about Himself, not an estimation of his theology.
Hence Life, harmony and presumably unity ensued
In a far more humble vein.
My takeaway from this might be that we need to address our ignorances than our theological certainties, to understand our calling as priests.
In the O.T. it is the priests /shepherds who are most
censured for the dire conditions of state and church
It was given to several kings and priests to restore/reform the Temple and Nation as God gave Wisdom knowledge and understanding; which were Paul’s priestly prayers in several letters for the
“Knowledge of Him” our great High Priest,and our union with Him.
Perhaps more later. Shalom.
Thank you! I do have notes on Job, but credit for the parts of them I gave above is really due to EL Greenstein, as mentioned.
“The world is not being invited to admire an institution that manages to hold together, but to believe something true, that the Father has sent the Son.”
But what ‘institution’ are to we have in mind here? And what Truth?
The Church Militant in any age will inevitably be an imperfect, fallen, human institution and therefore struggling and very often failing in the unending struggle against sin and error.
The Church Triumphant, on the other hand, is the ‘true’ institution which the is held up to the world for admiration by Christ. That serene and inviolate body which Christ has sanctified and cleansed that he might present it to himself in glory.
Was it not the this first sense of an ‘institution’ that Her Grace was speaking?
The Church of England is a broad church as established church, it includes conservative Anglo Catholics and open evangelicals, it includes liberal Catholics and conservative evangelicals. So they are never going to agree on all doctrine, some will be more high church, some more low church, let alone on female ordination, recognition of same sex relationships etc. So unity in the C of E is determined by the majority of what Synod votes for, in the House of Bishops, House of Clergy and House of Laity. If major changes are made to C of E doctrine they need to be approved by 2/3 of Synod, as say female bishops and clergy were and once that has been made then the C of E is effectively united on that issue (with an opt out sometimes for some Parishes and clergy that still disagree)
I’ve checked on AI, Jesus brings fire (Luke 12:49) first before unity.
I have a feeling that the AB used this text on unity to try and push members of the Synod to agree on her agenda and not God’s agenda. Christ wants true Christians to be united in the basic matters of faith and what the Bible says.
yes but the problem is many disagree on what the Bible says!
Yes, we need to ‘hold together unity with obedience, the friendship of Jesus with a readiness to obey his commands.’ But I think discovering what that means is a good deal less straightforward than is sometimes suggested. It’s one of the perpetual challenges of every church but especially Protestants and it’s partly why there are so many different denominations all claiming to have the correct set of beliefs, ethics and ways of organising their life together, all drawn from the Bible. With no central acknowledged authority (as the RC Church has) it’s impossible to maintain total unanimity, not least when deciding what matters of belief and ethics are of primary significance so that we cannot disagree over them. There’s no definitive and agreed mechanism for making those decisions. So if we want to be in a Protestant church (and I do) we have to live with that messiness and accept that being in a church will never have sharp edges and we’ll always have serious disagreements over some topics which some people will consider essential and others will view as negotiable. So what may be going on is not at root differences over doctrine or ethics (what we believe), or over theological method (Bible, tradition, reason, etc) but more personal differences of temperament or mindset – how far we each can live with those we disagree with and find in them brothers and sisters in Christ beyond our differences. Linked to that is how precisely and with what level of certainty we want to define beliefs and ‘prove’ them to be correct. And no one can control that.
Consider that if there are no denominations – i.e. hierarchies – then there cannot be schisms…
Every group has hierarchy. In anglicanism at least there is honesty about who that might be and some public transparent conversations about matters folk disagree on.
The NT knows nothing of a hierarchy that oversees multiple congregations. One the founding apostolos has passed on, each congregation *is* “the church in such-a-place”.
Then what is going on in Council of Jerusalem described in Acts 15?
The Council of Jerusalem was a meeting of apostoloi, and it is important to distinguish between apostolos and episkopos. An apostolos is a church planter. Episkopoi are overseers of a specific congregation and are part of it, the same men as its presbyteroi (compare Acts 20:17 and 20:28) – elders, one word denoting seniority and the other denoting function. Once an apostolos has ensured that a congregation he founded is mature and has the Holy Spirit, he appoints episkopoi and moves on to do the same elsewhere. He will retain authority over that congregation to his dying day, but as its founder he cannot be replaced.
The apostolic succession confuses the apostolos with an episkopos, and also supposes that there is one episkopos over many congregations when the New Testament has many episkopoi in one congregation.
So in your understanding the Council itself had no particular authority. It’s just that the founder of the Antioch church was there (traditionally Peter, though I think you can read Acts 11 as suggesting it’s Barnabas) and he agreed with the Council and he could then assert authoritatively his understanding (informed by the Council debate) over the Antioch church.
Non-denominational churches don’t have hierarchies?
Thanks Tim. This is helpful. I would add that no discussion of church unity is complete without considering Paul’s pastoral guidance to the divided church in Roman (Roms 14). At issue, then as now, was the whole identity of the church and its mission. How did Paul respond? Strikingly he does not approach the conflict in terms of right or wrong belief. Addressing both conservative Jewish and Gentiles believers Paul’s approach may be summarised thus: ‘If another holds a view that you disagree with, perhaps passionately, and that you may even consider to be a totally inappropriate belief for a Christian to hold, as long as that person has come to his or her views in conscious submission to the teaching of Christ, and holds it with a clear conscience, in thankfulness to God and aware of the coming Day when he/she will give account of themselves to God, then you are duty bound to welcome that sister or brother in the same way that Christ has welcomed you.’ (Chris Marshall)
David,
You are mixing apples and oranges here. Romans 14 concerns ‘the one who is weak in faith’ who insists on vegetarianism for some reason and marking certain days (presumably on the Jewish calendar). It isn’t about primary ethical matters (e.g. affirming homosexual relations) or primary doctrinal matters (e.g. denying the resurrection). Paul has plenty to say on those questions in his other letters. To assert that someone is ‘weak in faith’ means that he or she is immature and is not to be a leader and teacher in the church. So here in Romans 14 he is setting out a pastoral policy for peace in a church. How would you respond to a preacher who declared: ‘You must become vegetarians! And you must observe the Jewish calendar!’? I am pretty sure you would the first to say, ‘That person must not be teaching the congregation!’
Welcoming a sister or brother who is – Paul again – ‘weak in faith’ is not the same as allowing that person to be a leader or teacher. Rather it is trying to assist them in growth.
You also claim a bit too much for ‘conscience’. We must be wary of a certain modern Quaker understanding of ‘conscience’, as if each believer had a direct and infallible connection to God which was not subject to external correction. That isn’t what conscience means in the Bible or in Christian theology. Conscience is simply our interiorised sense of right and wrong. Like everything in us, it needs to be informed and matured.
For Paul, the debates with Judaizers and the Super Apostles were wholly on ethical matters. For Paul, the whole of the gospel was at stake. You cannot read his Letters at all attentively without realising this. Just because we (or at least some of us; there are Christians who won’t eat Halal meat), don’t regard diet and circumcision as ethical matters doesn’t mean that they weren’t first order issues for the early Christians. David is quite justified in using Romans 14 (and Acts 15 and Galatians) as analogues.
You have wholly missed out my point that Paul considered those with scruples on food and Jewish days as ‘weak in faith’. It’s the same with what he says in 1 Corinthians on meat offered to idols. His concern is always with the weaker brethren for whom Christ died, and the duties of those stronger in faith. That’s why he draws a distinction, and counsels peace between Jewish and Gentile Christians in the Roman church. Paul had no problem with Jews being circumcised, but he rejected extending it to Gentiles. David’s use of Romans 14 is confused and misses the point of that chapter.
David, any New Testament scholar would be amazed that you could write such a thing. It is obvious that there are negotiables and non-negotiables. The negotiables are always said to be the same things. You have tried to add other things to the negotiables list.
Paul is not talking here of ‘views’ (meaningless word). He was not a relativist. In fact, no-one has been less a relativist. Relativism (which is one huge convenient thought-free generalisation) is not held by people of conscience nor by philosophers of any standard.
Is the idea, David, that there is no such thing as actual right belief or actual wrong belief (as in – correct theories)?
I have long thought David is really a modern Quaker (as opposed to a 19th century Quaker, who were strict conservative evangelicals). Modern Quakers think that ‘inner light’ trumps other claims to truth and gives direct access to God (or whatever). That is why modern Quakers were keen to promote Richard Holloway’s atheist maunderings.
Inner light is infinitely flexible/malleable, and thus infinitely convenient to anyone who just wants to do what they want. Does evidence enter the picture anywhere at all? It must do. Awaiting elucidation.
How, David, can you quote Romans 14 as authoritative but not Romans 1?
Tim,
Why do you want to be in Protestant church? The only acceptable answer I can find to that is: ‘Because it teaches the true and sure way to eternal life.’
You write:
‘what may be going on is not at root differences over doctrine or ethics (what we believe), or over theological method (Bible, tradition, reason, etc) but more personal differences of temperament or mindset.’
Really? That isn’t what the Reformation was about. There were very real differences over doctrine and the sources of authority. You have glided over the theological issues too easily and ignored the fact that at issue is the sufficiency and the interpretation of the Bible. Liberalism asserts the deciding role of human reason and experience in whether the teaching of the Bible prevails or not. That’s really what it’s about. It’s not about temperament.
James, Thanks for this response. That isn’t my reason to prefer being a Protestant, it’s more to do with the claims made by the RC Church about itself which I don’t think can be sustained alongside some of its doctrinal assertions; the alternative in England is some form of Protestantism. I’m intrigued by the fact that some conservative evangelicals who’ve left the C of E in recent years have become RCs. The doctrines & the theological method are very different, so is it to do with temperament or the need for a church which claims absolute certainty? Do some forms of very trad RC faith and some forms of conservative evangelicalism share a family likeness underneath the doctrinal differences?
I didn’t claim anything about the Reformation but I fully agree substantive differences of doctrine and authority were involved. In fact, I think the example of Luther also makes my point: his temperament contributed to the path which the Reformation in Germany took. He was hardly an eirenic personality. The same point could be made about Spurgeon in the Downgrade Controversy. I was really only making an observation about how divisions arise and are handled today – ‘what may be going on.’ But that may not ever be the case in your experience. My experience is that personality/ temperament undoubtedly makes a difference in any dispute and can, sometimes, be clothed in a doctrinal/ ethical garb.
Tim,
I don’t know personally of conservative evangelicals who have left the C of E in recent years to become Roman Catholics, but no doubt there are some. Perhaps you know some and know their stories? If so, please mention them here. I am much more familiar with Anglo-Catholic Anglicans swimming the Tiber. I do know of some Protestants in America who have become Catholics – you can see them on Trent Horn’s and Matt Fradd’s youtube channels – but I would be cautious about using your ‘temperament’ (psychological) explanation, which is too easily reductionist: ‘You believe that because you are Type X on Myers-Briggs.’ Most of them say they found the Catholic case, once explained to them, as more persuasive, and they were fed up with divisions and contradictory teachings among Protestants.
No, Luther wasn’t always eirenic. Nor were the people who were trying to kill him. So the fact that wars broke out across Europe cannot be laid at the door of one man. Rather he exposed the profound divisions very close to the surface in European society. Thomas Cranmer was persuaded that Luther’s theology was correct; I think he knew how to distinguish between the man’s personality and his teaching, and so should we.
As for your last sentence: no, I don’t think the divisions in Protestantism over homosexuality or women in leadership are really to do with personal temperament. They are to do with what we make of the Bible in the modern world.
Maybe Michael Nazir-Ali fits Tim’s category? But I suspect the main reason that a conservative evangelical shifts from Canterbury to Rome is that he has had enough of liberal theology but is committed to the apostolic succession.
Nazir-Ali might fit that profile – although he was (I believe) a Roman Catholic in his youth. In England he came under John Stott’s sway. I had always thought of him as an ‘open evangelical’ because he ordained women. I don’t know that he has said much at all about his decision to become a Catholic, or that he had much to say about the ‘Anglican wars’.
It is interesting that a particular high profile Anglican to become Catholic, Gavin Ashenden, has been refused ordination as a Catholic priest. My on belief is that is because the RC hierarchy in England are afraid of him: he is much sharper and media-savvy than the rest of them and is always on youtube, GB News and other media opining about the latest stupidity from the C of E or the King. They can’t shut him up as a layman (and he has a huge international following), but a Father Gavin would be more than the liberal English hierarchy could cope with. So they’ve shut that door on him, while ordaining Nazir-Ali and lots of other Anglican clergy.
Significantly, one-third of all Catholic priests ordained in England since 1992 were former Anglican clergy, so Ashenden’s exclusion indicates he’s too hot to handle.
Gavin Ashenden has said publicly that if he were ordained by Rome then he would no longer be free to commentate on the British social and religious scene. Remember that he chose to resign as one of the late Queen’s honorary chaplains in order to speak – rightly – against the Quran reading in Glasgow episcopal cathedral (although personally I’d have let them sack me). I don’t think Ashenden has ever stated that he applied for the Catholic priesthood and was rejected, or was invited and turned it down; and Rome would never make such things public.
Nazir-Ali might have been an evangelical, but he was always one that was particularly open to Roman Catholicism. He was on the Anglican-Roman Catholic Intl Commission trying to bring about full communion for years. If you listen to how he tells it, his jump to the Roman Catholics was driven by a frustration at the lack of discipline within Anglicanism, particularly his experience of seeing his efforts to bring about unity with the Roman Catholics constantly undermined by other wings of the Church. Once the Ordinariate was established he had a route to moving over without having to give up the elements he most valued in Anglicanism.
Nazir-Ali was especially concerned about the moral anarchy he saw in Anglicanism over marriage and abortion, the inability of anyone to speak for the Anglican Communion any more in moral matters. I imagine he must have renounced his previous support for women’s ordination.
The amorality and/or passive and culpable neglect shown by the Church of England on abortion and marriage would be enough to send anyone packing. It is of dimensions that cannot be over-estimated.
On women’s ordination Nazir-Ali says he has changed his mind. I would suggest he is obediently suppressing his disagreement.
He was never on board with women bishops and the change there was the catalyst for his move to RCC, because Rome was so adamant it broke the agreement on ministry, and undermined any claim to apostolic succession. Now Nazir-Ali argues that the problem with women’s ordination is that it brings women into a male pattern of ministry, and we should instead ask what he regards as the more radical question: to what ministries is God calling women and men?
James, there are undoubtedly more catholic Anglicans who have become RCs that conservative evangelicals and that’s to be expected because of their views on issues such as priesthood, sacraments and the centrality of the church as historical institution. Michael Nazir Ali and Gavin Ashenden are mentioned below; Peter Forster might also be in the frame. What is so intriguing is that the doctrinal and ministerial views of the two traditions are so far apart and yet they have been able to change their minds so fundamentally. (For what it’s worth I have very little time for Myers-Briggs or other personality type assessments.) I would be fascinated to read a recent study of why people have converted (including from the RC church to the C of E) and what the mix of theology and personal attitudes is. I’m not suggesting that it’s only to do with personality/ temperament but I do notice sometimes that debates can be made more or less fractious and divisive depending on how the participants listen and engage with each other. As someone once put it to me, ‘how we disagree is as important as what we disagree about.’ I agree that Luther only contributed his part to the terrible conflicts of his day, but I was only making the point that his personality contributed to the course of events in the Reformation. After all some of his views were shared by Erasmus, but he took a different approach. And yes, I agree, current live issues over which there is serious disagreement are to do with how the Bible is read, but I don’t think it’s only that, because what one era says is completely non-negotiable a subsequent era finds it can accommodate differences on. Some today might take Spurgeon’s no compromise line from the 1880s, but I suspect today many, including many evangelicals, would think those disagreements in the form they then took belong to a bygone age.
Thank you Ian.
Would that we would absorb inwardly digest, rather than rush to comment with a querrelous push-back that in effect negates all that you have written here, while at the same time, seeks to be protestant, without attempting to define the category.
Whereas your article transcends, the politics, focussing on scripture alone.
Thanks again.
Interesting that you recommend reading John with his text in one hand and “with the synoptics, and particularly Mark, in the other”. When Dorothy L. Sayers was writing her wonderful play-cycle on the life of Jesus, “The Man Born To Be King”, she said in a letter to the BBC Director of Religious Broadcasting, “I find that when Mark and John are available they usually make sense, either separately or together”.
John 17 is not just about unity within the CofE – it is about the unity of the WHOLE international Church.
And the CofE’s established status makes that difficult because (a) churches elsewhere do not want to be formally united to the English state and (b) because an established church rather faces a situation of ‘serving two masters’ or being ‘unequally yoked’ with the world which makes its own internal unity difficult. See the following brief piece from my blog over ten years ago…..
“UNITY WITH ANGLICANISM
This was a response I recently put on a friend’s Facebook page; his post concerned the claim often made by anglicans that “evangelicals have no doctrine of the church”….
The trouble to my mind is that the Anglican doctrine of the church includes the idea of being a national body entangled with the state – in outright defiance of Jesus’ declaration that his kingdom is not of this world. That also makes ultimate Christian unity extremely difficult because most other Christians don’t want to be united with the whole English nation and entangled with English law as the Anglicans still too much are. Work with the Anglicans yes; formally unite with them still united to the state, NO!”
In addition, most other Christians don’t want to be united with each other. At least where I live, I see little enthusiasm among the Methodists, Baptists, Elim, New Frontiers, Salvation Army, Catholics, Vineyard …. for surrendering any part of their autonomy to one another.
So the issue is much wider than the specifically-Anglican state involvement. Rather, the issue is that most of us have accepted that having a choice of which church to belong to is natural and good. It is probably natural – but it isn’t good.
Reminds me of the old joke – how many psychiatrists does it take to change a lightbulb? One, but the lightbulb has to want to change.
It’s a great sadness to me to see the decline of the ecumenical movement from the 1980s onward. Did we have a moment within reach that we failed to grasp? Does the rise of consumerism that coinciding with a softening of hostility mean that we as congregants expect to be able to pick and choose to find our ‘perfect’ church?
The ecumenical movement is alive and well when churches are on mission together, and dies as soon as they are static and navel gazing.
The WCC got taken over by poverty theology and immediately then became just one denomination among many.
It had a startling sudden decline at (guess when?) end of 1960s and start of 1970s.
Jamie Wood – you see lack-of-unity where there isn’t any. I remember my time as a student at Edinburgh, where I affiliated myself to Holyrood Abbey. From time to time, for a change of scene, in common with other Christians I knew, I would go to the Buccleugh Free Church, or occasionally to Charlotte Chapel (Baptist) to hear Derek Prime. The churches had their own distinctive character, they were in different denominations, we all acknowledged that they were governed by the Spirit of God – nobody would have dreamed that they might be better off, or more Christian if they ‘surrendered any parts of their autonomy to one another’ (whatever that means). In short – I really don’t know what you mean here – or what your criticism is.
The difficulties within the C. of E. are actually very profound and haven’t been mentioned in this article (but I don’t imagine it will be too long before they do get an airing).
Jock
1. I define “denominationalism” as the existence of multiple denominations and congregations in a single area, each one running its own ministries with little reference to the others, and holding to the philosophy that it’s OK for an individual believer to choose to give his/her loyalty wherever he/she sees fit.
2. The arguments against it are explained by Bishop Lesslie Newbigin in “Foolishness to the Greeks” and by Bishop Colin Buchanan in “Is the Church of England Biblical?” I can give the barest summary here. Newbigin: “Denominationalism …. is the social form in which the privatisation of religion is expressed … Denominations (/congregations) cannot confront our culture with a witness to the Truth since even for themselves they do not claim to be more than associations of individuals who share the same private opinions.” Buchanan: “One of the most unbiblical features of this ‘choosing’ is that all are being invited to belong where they ‘fit,’ ie where there are like-minded people. This is comparable to Peter choosing only to eat with Jewish Christians in Antioch.” And “however much ministers may be …. praying together for the building up of each others’ congregations, at root they are in unspoken fierce competition, open to both the smugness of those who are winning a competition and aching sorrow and erosion of self-confidence for those who are losing it.” So “a desperate duplication of resources, a flush of buildings far beyond any realistic need of a properly organised church, and a shortage of ministers (and volunteers) who rush about in each others’ footsteps without even realising it.”
In my own town there are about 20 congregations. I asked AI to come up with an arbitrary town of the same size – AI said “Lowestoft” – and yes, Google Maps shows just under congregations in Lowestoft as well. In these godless days I suspect that two-thirds of the 20 are theologically orthodox. But: about 15 buildings requiring a maintenance schedule. 20 websites. 20 Sunday-school rotas. Probably around 15 churches trying to organise a youth ministry, more than half of which attract only a handful of participants. Around 15 sets of homegroups. Around 15 weekly prayer meetings, many badly-attended and most focussing on “our” ministries. Initiatives desperately seeking already-overworked volunteers to run them. Is that Unity?
If 20 congregations, then probably 4 or 5 Alpha courses!
When you say “churches elsewhere” do you just mean you? It didn’t seem to be a problem for Porvoo (which contains the CofE, the Church of Denmark, and the Church of Iceland). Is it a problem for the Greek Orthodox who are enshrined in the Greek constitution? Would the Catholics given the history of Roman Catholicism’s status and ties to the state in countries such as Malta, Argentina, Italy, Spain, etc. etc.)?
This call for obedience despite disagreement raises a question though. What are questions on which the rest of you disagree with the rest of the CofE, but nonetheless obey to your personal cost? Instead it seems that for everyone else personal conscience is allowed to triumph.
Interestingly, Yesterday the Oxford Union held a debate on
“This house believes that the Church of England’s days are numbered”.
Jayne Ozanne, it appears, withdrew from the debate when she discovered that the Most Revd Dr Foley Beach, former Primate of the Anglican Church in North America (ACNA) and chair of the Global Anglican Future Conference’s (Gafcon) primates’ council from 2018 to 2023 was to be a part of her involvement on the YES wing along with him, saying that she “Did not feel safe”
After all these decades it seems that dialogue or the lack of it just doesn’t cut it folks, is it time to attempt a different avenue ?
These have been somewhat circuitous Wilderness Years;
With folks revolving in their own circles. What circles do we move in ?
Mercifully God is well able to “..restore to you the years that the swarming locust has eaten, The crawling locust,
The consuming locust, And the chewing locust,
My great army which I sent among you. Joel 2 v 15
But only if we fulfil the conditions of vs. in Joel 2 v 15 – 17
And only then might we hope that God might turn and leave a blessing behind Him Joel 2 v. 14.
The motif of the Wilderness Years are most instrumental In bringing “many sons into glory”.
It serves as a pivotal motif of testing, formation, and encounter with God rather than mere aimless wanderings [going round in circles]
Not forgetting of course Paul’s observation that those ancients are examples to us, upon which the ends of the age are come. We need a breaking of the circles. Shalom.
Apologies.
The above debate reported by –
.anglicanfutures.org/post/does-jayne-ozanne-have-reason-to-feel-unsafe
It is possible that Jayne Ozanne does indeed ‘feel unsafe’ in the company of Foley Beach but, although she is the final arbiter of her feelings, she is not the final arbiter of their rationality. She owes it to the Oxford Union to explain *exactly* why she has withdrawn from the debate.
Contrast her behaviour with that of Bradford convert from Islam to Christianity Nissar Hussain, who had far stronger grounds for feeling unsafe – which were, unfortunately, justified, but it did not stop him.
I understand the speakers list was decided several weeks ago, so it’s very strange that she has reacted this late. Was she not paying attention weeks ago? There’s a lot of ‘not feeling safe’ today, but to the best of my knowledge, no speakers at the Oxford Union have ever been assaulted – not even Charlie Kirk – although he was harangued by the student who became the president (briefly) and gloated in Kirk’s murder.
Wilderness Years, where nothing Grows, blossoms or fruits are fundamental to God’s purpose.
Those who are “led of the Spirit” will be led as the ancients Into the wildernesses to “try” i.e. prove,
test, and temper.
“LIFE is not as idle ore but iron dug from central gloom
Heated hot and battered by the shocks of doom
And dipped in baths of hissing tears to shape and use.
[Sufficiently Impressed.]
The Wilderness is where and when Over-comers are
prepared for real, effective, fruitful ministry .
Purged of the flesh and filled with all the fulness of God.
Moses spent forty years in Midian before encountering God at the burning bush; Elijah retreated into the wilderness (1 Kings 19); and David lived as a fugitive in desert spaces before becoming king.
[John the Baptist, Jesus and Paul before ministry begins]:
Prophets like Hosea and Jeremiah later looked back at the wilderness as a time of early devotion and renewal, while Isaiah envisioned the barren wilderness blooming into a restored garden.
Jesus enters the wilderness for forty days of fasting and temptation (Matthew 4; Luke 4), succeeding where Israel’s wilderness generation failed through reliance on Scripture and obedience to God.
Early Christian writers frequently frame the believer’s life between redemption and final restoration as a journey through a spiritual wilderness toward a promised inheritance.
The Wilderness years are never wasted years but an opportunity for God with his saints,
Murmurers, Complaining and faithless folks only perish
In the wilderness years.
Press on to higher ground.
Shalom.