The lectionary epistle for the Third Sunday before Advent in Year A is 1 Thessalonians 4.13-18. This is notorious for being used to teach the idea of the ‘secret rapture’ of believers before Jesus’ return, so that those who are alive are snatched up to heaven.
The Greek term harpazo is translated in the Vulgate by the Latin verb rapio (from which we get ‘rapture’). But Paul is using the analogy of the emperor coming to visit a city—something the Thessalonians will know well—and the direction of travel is consistently downwards. There is no change in direction for King Jesus arriving into City Earth. Indeed, the language he uses is found elsewhere in the New Testament for people going out to greet a visiting dignitary, and then accompanying them into the city—not going away from it with them!
The phrase ‘Prince of Power of the Air’ is in Ephesians 2.2; Ian was right about the letter but wrong about the chapter.
The article about the meaning of clouds in scripture is here.
The gospel reading this week is Matthew 25.1-13, the parable of the wise and foolish virgins awaiting the bridegroom—which includes an example of people going out to meet the visitor and then accompanying him in. The written commentary on that reading is here
and the video discussion is here.








Just pondering; Paul writing to these very new Christians at Thessaloniki makes this statement. Did he mislead them?
Was he miss led by the Spirit? Is it a false statement/ hope?
Are the great multitude and the overcoming 144,000 in heaven or on
Earth?, they cannot be a group made perfect without us, just as the OT. saints could not be made perfect without the church/eclessia?
In the Jewish economy the bridegroom goes to the bride’s
House and takes them to His Father’s house.
John 14:2 In my Father’s house are many mansions: if it were not so, I would have told you. I go to prepare a place for you.
14:3 And if I go and prepare a place for you, I will come again, and receive you unto myself; that where I am, there ye may be also.
How and When these things do eventually pan out we need to
Watch and Wait. These things are written for our present comfort
[strengthening ]. Shalom.
Forgive me, but I am not sure I know what you’re asking here. Are you suggesting that Paul deliberately intended to deceive or mislead the Thessalonians by giving them false hope, or worse, that the Holy Spirit is capable of deliberate misdirection and deceit of the Apostles?
I think you could make a case, perhaps, that the Thessalonians may have been given to extract a false hope from Paul’s teaching (but this is very subjective), but it is a bit of a stretch to say that Paul intended them to. Perhaps I’ve misunderstood you?
Are the great multitude and the overcoming 144,000 in heaven or on Earth?
If I may attempt an answer to this, based on what Ian has written m any times:
First, they are the same group. The 144,000 are an army that John ‘hears’ being assembled, as per the book of Numbers. When John subsequently turns around and ‘sees’ them, following the pattern of the letter thus far, this army is revealed not to be ethnically Jewish (and male) soldiers dressed in armour, as we might have expected, but ethnically diverse (male and female) worshippers dressed in white. Second, as to location, they are with Christ, before the throne (as stated in verse 9). Therefore, however we conceive of their location, it is certainly not Earth.
Mat
I find the interpretation of John 14:2 as Jesus’ using a phrase which a bridegroom would use with his bride as curious.
In the first place ‘you’ is plural. Secondly, at least according to Gen 2:24, before the ‘cleaving’, i.e. joining, a man “leaves his father and mother”. Why does the groom take his bride to his father’s house?
Then, Jesus is speaking to a bunch of blokes. What would they think? To use a modern analogy, imagine the coach of a football team saying to his players: “when I come back I’m going to take you all on honeymoon.”
The word monē (‘house’) in v2 occurs late in v23, where Jesus describes that for the loving, and therefore obedient, disciple, that the Father and he will come to him and “make our monē with him”. Then add in that monē is related to the verb menō (‘remain’ or ‘abide’) found in John 15, and you get rather a different picture of things.
Having now listened to the video, there is much to
encourage [strengthen] us and some that seems to me
quite nonsensical, more none -Scriptural imagination.
In the account of the ten virgins, a sudden arrival {“You know not the
Day nor the Hour”} Says Jesus.
They go out to meet him and he takes them to His Father’s house
There to be provided with wedding garments [ white Robes?]
Thus they descend as a bride prepared out of heaven.
To compare the coming of the Lord as a mere Roman Emperor!
would be strange to modern ears, “where did that come from”?
they might rightly ask, whereas an earnest enquirer might lean towards a Jewish apostolic idiom in line with the whole counsel of God .
“Let no one rob you of the simplicity that is in Christ Jesus”
Perhaps the “Bishops” might give a lead on this? Shalom.
‘To compare the coming of the Lord as a mere Roman Emperor!’
Do you know the meaning of the word ‘parousia’ which we explain in the video? Do you know where it comes from and how it was used?And what it would mean to Paul’s first audience…?
Except Paul uses the same word in 2 Thess regarding the man of lawlessness. There he paints a picture of this man appearing shortly, presumably in the 50s or 60s, but then be destroyed by Jesus’ parousia, which you have consistently argued always referred to Jesus’ physical return. Jesus did not return then. Perhaps parousia should not be given that limited meaning.
Colin Hemer in his “The Letters to the Seven Churches of Asia” makes reference to the use of parousia, e.g.
“The term parousia was widely used for the official visit of a potentate.” (p74)
This is in reference of the custom of the visiting potentate to receive a victor’s crown (stephanos, not a royal crown) from those visited. In contrast, Jesus in his parousia gives those who have been faithful the crown of life.
He also comments:
“Belief in the imminent Parousia of Christ had evidently waned.” (p145)
Nice. I agree with the first. I am not convinced by that second quotation…!
A Hebrew Idyll
Quote – “You remember that beautiful romance of the Old Testament,
It is so well known now, but it is a perfect illustration of this thing.
Abraham and his servant, and the vow of the servant, going to a far country, another country, to find a bride for Isaac.
The servant setting out, taking with him the treasures of Abraham’s house, arriving at his destination and putting God to the test, and the seal of God coming upon his quest, and there he discovers the bride, and then all kinds of things set to work to try and cause delay,
to keep the bride back.
They want to detain, or entertain, the servant rather than
respond to what he is after
. So today, we want to keep, to entertain, to have the Spirit, and the Spirit is here for a purpose.
They tried to entertain him, to hold back the thing for which he had come, to be nice to him.
But the Holy Spirit has none of it, Eliezer has none of it,
he says;
“Look here, I am not going to stay here, I want to know if you are going to accede to the thing for which I have come,” and in spite of all the manoeuvring, he comes to the point, and says “now about the business,” and they have to put the question straight to Rebecca,
“wilt thou go with this man?” and, without any hesitation, she said
“I will go”; and he brought out the treasures of his master’s house, and adorned her and led her away.
Now, beloved, the Spirit has come on behalf of the Lord, He has come here to get the Bride for Christ
. He has come with the riches of His grace to adorn that Bride, to speak of the glories of the Bridegroom and His inheritance: but the Holy Spirit is not going to be entertained or detained,
He is come on business, and He is saying “Are you coming, are you coming with Me?”
His business by a covenant with God is that He will do His work thoroughly, present the issue clearly. And so, the Holy Spirit is here to get us on a journey, the end of which is to find the Lord Jesus coming out to meet us as Isaac went out from the house; out on the way, doubtless anticipating, expecting, scanning the horizon, waiting, eagerly waiting”.
https://austin-sparks.net/english/001599.html
He is there at the beginnings of the Divine Covenants,
The Advent ,the baptismal dedication, the Cross,
the Resurrection, the Ascension , the birth and Life of the Church.
He is even there at the divine assessment of the churches in Revelation. So the Spirit brings them all to birth, He is the executor of the will of God.
The Jews were well aware of the genesis of the bridegroom and
and the bride. Shalom.
No Matt, If there will be no rapture as some seem to suggest
that there will not be, Is Paul miss leading them and us in saying
that there will be?
If, as suggested that , the dead in Christ are just that i.e. in some state of sleep waiting for His return and consummation.
Who then are the 144,000 and the great multitude of Rev. 7 and 14 ?
Shalom.
‘ Is Paul miss leading them and us in saying
that there will be?’
Paul doesn’t tell them there will be a rapture. That is the whole point of this video.
The 144,000 are the Israel of God now in Jesus, as I explain in my commentary and in my articles on that passage.
In which case Ian it does not make any sense at all to me. Shalom.
Do you not understand the word ‘parousia’?
Not being an educated chap I can only read “defective” incompetent
bible translations of the Greek and Hebrew. Shalom.
Well, we explain the word carefully in the video. I hope that helps.
Hi Ian, re your “the direction of travel is consistently downwards.” Harpazo by no means requires a downward direction. It includes snatch up, carry off by force, sudden swoop, snatch/steal money or prisoner of war. Look at Paul’s words: ‘we will be snatched in/among the clouds to a face-to-face (thus antao) meeting with the Lord in(to) the air.’ The direction is up into the air.
Thereafter we will always be with the Lord; Paul does not here say where that will be.
Re your “Paul doesn’t tell them there will be a rapture. That is the whole point of this video.”. Well, he doesn’t say there will be a secret rapture along with all the other items that go with a certain understanding of ‘THE RAPTURE.’ But he sure promises us a rapture into the air.
We are snatched up to meet the Lord just as elders leave a city to rush to meet the emperor.
When they meet the emperor, who turns around? Where do they then go?
A: they do. And they then enter the city together.
That is exactly the image Paul is drawing on. Nowhere does it say the Jesus changes his direction of travel and heads back into heaven…
Doesnt it make sense though that believers physically leave the earth, even if temporarily, to meet Jesus. Otherwise how could so many billions actually meet him?
Also how does this all fit in with the final judgment? The NT seems to say ALL (believers and unbelievers) will be raised and judged.
They leave in the same way that elders leave a city to greet the ruler as he comes to them. No more and no less. This is the language Paul is using.
I would love to know how billions of people can go out to meet him by walking.
Paul was writing at a time when there were few believers compared to the general population, so it was easy for him to imagine them leaving a city and walking to meet Jesus. That image cant apply now.
“Also how does this all fit in with the final judgment? The NT seems to say ALL (believers and unbelievers) will be raised and judged.”
The ‘raising’ of the dead in, say, 1 Corinthians 15 (the longest sustained treatment of the topic) is always a raising life, and not a raising off the ground. In both cases they are literal raisings, but are describing quite different things. If it meant the latter, then Paul’s reference in verse 4 of Jesus being “raised on the 3rd day” would seem to be confusing the Resurrection and Ascension.
I think the New Testament picture of the last judgement is of raising to life (resurrection) and then being brought into the presence of God for said Judgement. Granted, locating that spatially is difficult, but the language of ‘standing before’ the throne, and the image in revelation, does seem to preclude it taking place hovering in the air.
I dont disagree with ‘raising’. I was asking more how Ian envisages the final judgement fits in with Jesus’ return to earth. Do believers go out to meet him, then accompany him back. Are then unbelievers resurrected/raised so that all face judgement? And how dos the Millenium fit into this scenario?
I also think James in the video too easily dismisses Paul’s words ‘We who are still alive..’. I strongly suspect Paul really did believe Jesus was going to return in his lifetime, but was wrong. This correlates with his 2nd letter to the Thessalonians where he appears to say although the man of lawlessness was already present, he was being held back and would be revealed in due course. But Jesus’ return (‘parousia’) would destroy him. That is why some think he was referring to Nero who rose to power about 2 years from the date of this letter. But he was not destroyed by Jesus’ return so Paul got it wrong. Otherwise you have to argue the man of sin is still future, but that does not fit with the scenario Paul painted in AD50/51.
I like to imagine the bishops of the seven churches wanting to be the first to greet St. John and escort him ashore. They row out—six on the oars and the gubernator at the rudder of their little boat, Pleiades—approaching the Nimbus to bring him safely home. All is done in the same spirit as those who went down to the Jordan to fetch King David from exile, keen to show John their fealty after reading his Revelation. John’s feet never touch the ground, they carry him high.
The difference in the Rapture and Second Advent is that the Rapture is where Jesus comes back for the Church, whereas the Second
Advent is when Jesus comes to the Earth with His church (Rev. 19:14).
19:14 And the armies which were in heaven followed him upon white horses, clothed in fine linen, white and clean.
The Rapture is God`s rescue plan for the Church and the Second Advent is God`s rescue plan for Israel . It is important to note all the differences between the Rapture and the Second Advent. In the Rapture, Christ comes to take the church out of harm’s way, and in the Second Advent Christ returns to destroy evil and establish His Millennial Kingdom.
We know that the great multitude and the 144, 000 are the overcoming saints clothed in white linen.
Note the occurrences of the term “white raiment”
in Revelation, particularly. Rev 3:5, 3:18, 4:4, 6:11, 7:9, 7:13–14,
19:8, 19:14 .
These are not “new Heavens “people
they appear again in Rev. 19 v 14 as the army of the Lamb in His coming wars. Cf Rev 17 v 14 Victory for the Lamb
17 v 14 These will wage war against the Lamb, and the Lamb will overcome them because He is Lord of lords and King of kings; and those who are with Him are the called and chosen and faithful.”
Jesus does not come alone on His return. Was there a Rapture
before this Second coming. ? Shalom.
Alan you have made seven comments here, almost none of which engage at all with the content of the video.
I wonder if you could moderate your comments and give space to those who do? Thanks
Pity. Unworthy response to straightforward observations based on Scripture. Sense of human wisdom in podcast struggling to make the straightforward reading of Scripture inaccessible an complex. Believers in Christ will* be caught up to meet the Lord *in the air just as is promised in Acts and reinforced here in 1Thess 4. This is not a ‘secret’ (human words inserted by podcasters) but it is truly a ‘mystery’ in NT sense – previously hidden truth, now revealed. ‘Behold I tell you a mystery…’
As noted elsewhere in these comments, ‘rapture’ may be a loaded term, but let’s not lose the truth of 1 Thess 4 which fits with Jesus teaching in Mt 24 and Jn 14 – ‘I will receive you to myself, that where I am, there you may be also’ – unlike podcast, note the direction of travel ‘receive you to myself’.
Why unworthy? Alan has put up a sequence of verses, and then made claims that they don’t support, as a comment on a video the contents of which he does not appear to have engaged with.
John 14 is about Jesus receiving the disciples in fellowship once he has dealt with their sin on the cross. It is not about post-mortem destiny.
What we have done in the video is actually engage with what the text says, the language Paul uses, the image he is drawing on, and the meaning it would have carried for his first readers.
What in that do you disagree with?
Thank you
Unworthy because of sense that your view is simply correct and unchallengeable! As John Lennox notes (commentary on Revelation 2025), we need to come to these areas with a degree of humility. I’m interested to read your views – they seem an honest attempt to explore Scriptural truth. But they, like all views and opinions ( including my own:). ), need tested in the light of Scripture. In these particular areas, Christians may disagree. So unworthiness comes when we don’t honour other views, even if we hold a different understanding.
John 14 is a case in point. You make a strong (strident) case for your view. I would differ. The context is not of receiving into fellowship imv, but on the truth of the Lords imminent departure from the disciples post His resurrection. So ‘we don’t know where you are going,so how can we know the way ?’ The truth of John 14 (let not your hearts be troubled) is not about fellowship but about the Believers eternal confidence and security in trouble and in Death.
No, my view is not unchallengeable. I welcome challenge and it happens a lot.
What Alan does in these comments is not challenge; he simply ignores the video and asserts another view, one that (as we actually show in the video!) is not supported by the text.
On John 14, see my article here: https://www.psephizo.com/biblical-studies/what-are-the-place-prepared-and-the-greater-works-in-john-14/
Alan does not seem to be engaging at all with what was said in the video. If what was said about the 1st century context of the use and understanding of perusia and the conventions of a visit by a dignitary within a highly status oriented society, is wrong, then please explain why it is incorrect. It is a basic exegetical principle that the core meaning of a text is how its recipients, i.e. 1st century Thessalonians in this case, would have understood it.
If that understanding conflicts with your theology, well, which is likely to be wrong?
As Rev 20 tells us, there are two resurrections. One precedes the millennial kingdom of God, the other terminates it. ‘Blessed and holy is the one who shares in the first resurrection, [for] … they will be priests of God and of Christ, and they will reign with him.’ This is the ‘resurrection of the righteous’ (Luke 14:14). Until that moment, the dead in Christ remain in the earth.
1 Thes 4, last para, describes this first resurrection. By definition, it is upward in trajectory. ‘The dead in Christ will rise first. Then we who are alive, who are left, will be caught up together with them in the clouds to meet the Lord in the air, and so we will always be with the Lord.’ The same moment is described in Matt 24:40-42. Also I Cor 15. ‘The trumpet [as in I Thes 4:16] will sound, and the dead will be raised imperishable, and we shall be changed.’
Further exegesis is given in my commentary on John’s Revelation, When the Tower Falls: A Prophecy of What Must Happen Soon. I avoid the term ‘rapture’, which generates unnecessary controversy and is a distraction.
‘1 Thes 4, last para, describes this first resurrection.’
Except it doesn’t, does it? There is nothing at all in Paul’s language to suggest two separate events—let alone separate by 1,000 years!
For Paul, there is clearly a single event, in which both those who have died and those left behind still living, are involved.
And the word he uses for that is ‘parousia’.
It’s a fascinating passage because, as you point out, it’s addressing a concern that is quite alien to us – not just a concern that we don’t have, but that we struggle to comprehend. It seems to be that the people of Thessalonica are worried about being separated from those who have died before them. When you read about Greek ideas of the afterlife, it’s a pretty miserable affair, with the dead slouching about indistinguishably and getting irritated if someone interferes with their graves. You don’t get a sense of reunion: the dead are in the afterlife, but they’re gone. Hence, the mythology of Orpheus who tries to rescue his wife Eurydice from the underworld, not join her in it.
St Paul paints a startlingly different picture for Christians. We are to be together again – the living and the dead. Reading between the lines you get the impression that the Thessalonians have a concern that something bad has happened to the dead. They need to be reassured by St Paul that the dead aren’t going to be abandoned: “God will bring with him those who have died”. Nor are they destined to be some sort of 2nd class citizens of heaven: those living don’t have precedence over them, and in fact “the dead in Christ will rise first”. Perhaps 2000 years of Christian thought bouncing around the culture means that today it’s hard to find someone who thinks the dead might be left behind in some way.
The meeting of the Lord also really matters. The formal apenthesis is not just the elders/dignitaries/citizens going out to meet the Emperor. On meeting him they form part of his escort to go into the city. This union is the key element: we’re not just together with each other, we’re united with Christ, and that is why the resurrection matters as what enables that union for us. And that is why in Ephesians 5 St Paul uses the marriage imagery to make the point that we united with Christ: “the two will become one flesh”. And famously in Galatians 3 we are told that “in Christ all are children of God… There is neither Jew nor Gentile, neither slave nor free, nor is there male and female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus.”
Lovely exposition Adam—I entirely agree.
Me too. With you both.
That is excellent Adam. I had not thought of it this way before. The dead are not left behind, they not forgotten.
This article is a measured discussion of the ‘rapture’:
https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/essay/the-rapture-question/
One thing seems clear to me. The resurrection of deceased Christians and the transformation of them and those still living will be a public and noisy event. This does not seem to fit the common views of any ‘rapture’ (and there is not even agreement as to when it will be).
When will it be? At the end of the age. When The New Jerusalem containing all the living stones descends from heaven to earth. It’s the only building that is built from the top down. When the final stones are placed on the penultimate layer it will almost touch the ground, then the ones who have experienced the first resurrection, you and me, will be swept up into it just before it touches the ground.
Some notes I made earlier on this passage (my main source – as usual – James Philip).
1 Thessalonians 4:13,14 certainly introduces a passage that is full of rich teaching and instruction about the Last Things. The passage is a response to some confusion in the Thessalonians’ minds as to the exact repercussions that the Return of Christ to establish His kingdom would have. While they waited for His coming, some of their number had died, and the question arose as to what was their position in relation to the
coming glory. Denney puts it this way: ‘Had they been robbed, by death, of the Christian hope? Had the inheritance which is incorruptible, undefiled and imperishable, passed for ever beyond their grasp, because they had died before Christ came to take His people to Himself?’ Paul wrote the passage to correct such mistaken ideas and tells them, quite categorically, that it is not the will of God that they should have any doubts about either the safety or the well being of loved ones who had died in Christ. Paul is *not* saying that Christians may sorrow, but not to the same degree or extent as the heathen do; taking it this way would miss the point. The sorrow is ‘concerning them that sleep’, and about their ‘fate’, not the sorrow we may feel for ourselves. Believers feel very deep pain and distress in bereavement; the Christian Faith should create a tenderness of heart of a kind unknown outside the faith. But the believer who falls asleep in Christ is surely not to be sorrowed over, for not only has he not lost anything, but on the contrary has gained immeasurably. He is gone to be with Christ, which is far better. Pagan sorrow mourned the dead because they had been cut off from all that makes for life; this, says Paul, must surely be impossible for one who believes in Christ, for the dead in Christ are not thus cut off. We may weep for ourselves in our loss, but we need not weep for those we have lost, if they are Christ’s, for they are beyond the reach of hurt or loss. They are the blessed dead.
The reason Paul gives for the assurance in 13 is that the bond that unites the believer with Christ is one that death can never break. The ‘last enemy’ can never drive a gulf between the soul and the Saviour. If Jesus died and rose again, then those that sleep in Him, God will bring with Him when He comes again because they are indissolubly united to Him. The words in Romans 8:38, that ‘neither death nor life…. shall be able to separate us from the love of God’ are meant to be taken literally as well as seriously. We are one with Christ, and He is one with us, in life and death alike, and in every conceivable circumstance, and those who sleep in Him are no more dead than He is dead. It would be true to say that He cannot come without them, since He is bound to them and they to Him in such an intimate union. ‘He that is joined to the Lord is one spirit’ says Paul elsewhere (1 Corinthians 6:17). One further and blessed implication of this is that believers who die are not even separated from fellow believers who are left, for those that are united to Christ are thereby united to one another, and this means that the communion of saints is not disturbed by death either. In this sense also believers do not sorrow in the same way as those who have no hope.
In 1 Thessalonians 4:15-18, Paul is giving the final assurance for what he has been emphasising; there will in fact be no difference between believers who are alive and remain at Christ’s coming and believers who have already died, for it will simply be a question of the resurrection of the dead taking place for them to join the living (who will have been changed), and together being caught up to be with the Lord forever. To have died in Christ or to be alive and remain is all one for the believer, so far as the coming of the Lord is concerned. The ‘dead in Christ’ are said to ‘sleep in Jesus’ and there is great significance in the contrast with what is said of Christ. He ‘died’; believers ‘fall asleep’. This is a contrast that persists throughout the New Testament (cf John 11:11, ‘Our friend Lazarus sleeps’: Mark 5:39, ‘The damsel is not dead, but sleeps’: 1 Corinthians 11:30, ‘Many sleep’). What we call death, Jesus called sleep. Death as we know it is, for believers, but a sleep. But Jesus did not sleep, in this sense; He died. Death is not the bodily agony He endured, only, or the cessation of life as such, but that from which His soul shrank in Gethsemane and finally experienced in the hours of infinite suffering in the darkness of the Cross – death as the wages of sin – when God turned away His face from Him. That is death, and no one who believes in Him shall ever die that death. He has died that death in our place. This is the basis of the assurance Paul gives the Thessalonians. As to the position of the ‘Dead in Christ’, ‘ The bodies of men after death return to dust, and see corruption, but their souls (which neither die nor sleep) having an immortal subsistence, immediately return to God Who gave them. The souls of the righteous, being then made perfect in holiness, are received into the highest heavens, where they behold the face of God in light and glory, waiting for the full redemption of their bodies’ (Westminster Confession, 32:1).
That the coming of Christ is a personal coming (‘The Lord Himself’), and cannot be spiritualised to mean either the coming of the Spirit at Pentecost (Paul’s words here were written long after Pentecost!), or to the coming of death to the believer (does not Paul make a distinction between death and the Coming in this very passage?) is surely clear from what is said in these verses. Even within the ranks, however, of evangelicals who do believe in a personal return of Christ there is wide divergence of view as to its exact meaning and significance. Two points of significance: the first is to ‘identify’ the event; and this is possible when we compare what the Apostle says here with his statements in 1 Corinthians 15:51ff, and with our Lord’s own words in Matthew 24:29 31, and with John’s in Revelation 8. Consistency of interpretation should make it clear that the trumpet in each of these passages refers to the same event, and that this event must necessarily take place at the end of time. The last trumpet ushers in the judgment and the Day of God. The second point is that this necessarily means a general resurrection of both just and unjust at the same time. Objections to this idea stems from a misunderstanding of Revelation 20 which, it is averred, proclaims two resurrections, separated by the space of a thousand years. But we must remember that Revelation is apocalyptic, and when there are plain statements elsewhere in Scripture saying the opposite, it is surely wisdom to start with them, and interpret apocalypse in the light of them, and not vice versa. Jesus’ words in John 5:28, 29, echoed by Paul in Acts 24:15, are quite unequivocal as emphasising a general resurrection, whereas Revelation 20 speaks of the *souls* of the righteous, not their bodies.
I’ve said this previously when the ‘Rapture’ and related things have come up….
1) Yes, there is a ‘rapture’ because that is the meaning of the word ‘harpazo/caught up’. What there is not is a ‘rapture’ which seizes the Church away and leaves the earth for a period (seven actual or symbolic years?) with further history to occur before Jesus returns with the Church to deal with everybody else, the ‘left behind’.
I’d suggest that the ‘caught up’ is simply because unlike an earthly emperor coming to a city along a road, Jesus is coming down from heaven (and with more surprise than there would be with the earthly approach of an emperor) and so those who ‘go out’ to meet him will also be ‘caught up’ into the air. Jesus’ “Advent” includes as a single event his coming to earth and the meeting on the way with the Christians both the risen dead and the still alive.
2) The idea of a gap of years of further history between Rapture and Advent was as I understand it unknown until the prophetic Millennial movement started by Edward Irving in the early 1800s. Irving and his colleagues preached a second coming which might be ‘any second now’ and after a few years of such preaching they were ‘hyped up’ to the point they could not accept a delay.
Unfortunately as they studied prophecy they soon realised that there were a lot of unfulfilled prophecies which needed to be fulfilled before the End and wouldn’t be if Jesus were indeed to appear in the next few minutes as the end of history. John Nelson Darby and others worked on this, and the Rapture taking the Church away while history continued for a while was the ‘solution’ to that unfulfilled prophecy problem. We the Church would all be taken away while among other events the world would suffer antiChrist and Tribulation and Jewish destiny would be fulfilled by a return to the Land, rebuilding of the Temple, and eventually the Conversion of the Jews.
Had they been less ‘hyped up’ they might have realised that they were creating an artificial problem. II Thessalonians describes a comparable situation of over enthusiasm about the Advent and Paul says not to get all stirred up about it; there are prophecies yet to be fulfilled – he specifically mentions the ‘man of lawlessness’ – and in effect until they see those fulfilments they can scale back from ‘Red Alert’ to ‘Amber Alert’. The 19thC movement could have applied that principle to the unfulfilled prophecies they had discovered and accepted a delay. But they couldn’t emotionally accept that so they came up with the scheme we now know.
It is ironic that the possible delay they were so hyped up about is still ongoing; they would not have believed it!! And considerable adjustments in the scheme were needed in 1948 when modern Israel was founded; logically those following the original idea should have gone into total panic as they would clearly have been left behind…..