Are resolutions the best way to change?

calendar8Have you set your New Year’s resolutions yet? One day in, have you managed to keep them all? It’s a serious question, since we know from bitter experience that New Year’s resolutions seem to disappear faster than a cold turkey sandwich. Here are seven questions to help you think through your resolutions for the year to come.

1. Is this the right time? ‘There is a season for everything under the sun’ (Eccl 3.1)

When I was running a squash league at the gym I went to, I discover something shocking about how gyms work: they run on the membership fees of those who never attend. Only around a third of the paid-up members ever attended regularly, and many of the no-shows had signed up in January. Gyms usually see something like 50% of their new business for the year in January, but 80% of these have stopped attending by the second week of February.

The reason for that is, in the Western calendar, January is not the natural time to make changes. We have not had a long break from our occupation; we have not had time and space to re-evaluate our lives. That usually comes in August—which means September is the real start to the new year for many people. So, if you are not feeling very resolved, why not put a note in your diary to make a resolution in nine months’ time?

2. Are you ready for change? ‘Repent and believe the good news’ (Mark 1.15)

The last time we moved house, I noticed that I found a lot of things about daily living annoying and exhausting. The silliest example was to do with our curtains. The previous owners obviously had a thing about fancy curtains with pelmets and pull chords. To open or close the curtains you could not just yank them—you had to find the chord, pull it to open the curtain, and then use the tie-back to secure it. I felt I was frittering my life away with all this chord pulling!

Now, I rather enjoy this routine. So what was different when we had first moved in? It represented a change to daily living, and change can feel exhausting, even in the simple things of life. If you are going to change something this New Year, be ready for it to take emotional energy. If you don’t have that energy, you might soon find change is just too demanding.

3. What will you stop doing? ‘Be still and know that I am God’ (Ps 46.10)

Many New Year’s resolutions fail because we are just trying to pack yet another thing into our already hectic schedules. One of the most helpful writers on time management (which is really about self management) is Mark Forster. He notes that we fail to get things done because we never give a task ‘sufficient focused attention’, and the reason for that is very often that we are over committed. To do more, sometimes we need to aim for less.

So, if you have resolved to do something new this year, what are you going to stop doing to give you the space to tackle the new thing properly?

4. Will you be encouraged? ‘I never stop giving thanks to my God because of you’ (Eph 1.16)

Management theory tells us that our goals ought (amongst other things) to be ‘stretching’. That might sound like good advice, but when does ‘stretching’ become ‘breaking’?

I am always wanting to improve my language skills, and I came across a great website called Duolingo. I wanted to do well, so I set myself a stretching goal for each day. Sometimes I made it, sometimes I didn’t. But when life was busy, the days I didn’t make my goal started to outnumber the days I did, until it petered out altogether. Then I did something radical: I reduced my goal to the minimum possible. It was very easy to reach, taking just five minutes, so every day I got an encouraging message ‘You have reached your goal! Well done!’ Net result? I am studying much more than I did—and on average I am easily exceeding my previous ‘stretching’ goal!

5. Do you have a ‘change buddy’? ‘Let us consider how we may spur one another on toward love and good deeds.’ (Hebrew 10.24)

Something else that has encouraged me in my language study is a little feature on the bottom right of the page which shows how well my friends are doing. It might just be my competitive spirit, but when I see someone else is making progress, it encourages me to do the same.

One of the slogans for feminists in recent years has been ‘If you can’t see it, you can’t be it.’ In other words, for many women if they cannot see other women being role models in particular arenas, it is much harder to imagine themselves in those positions. In fact, that is true for all of us. If someone else is doing the thing we aspire to in our resolutions, it is much easier to keep going with this new commitment. So find a ‘change buddy’ who will share your New Year commitment—and encourage each other to keep it!

6. Do you want to change? ‘Be transformed by the renewing of your mind’ (Romans 12.2)

‘To live is to change, and to be perfect is to have changed much.’ This saying is usually attributed to the leader of the Oxford Movement in the nineteenth century, John Henry Newman. But in another version it is attributed to Winston Churchill.

Both are pointing out a key truth about life: if we never change, if we are stuck in a rut, then we will never grow to maturity—and in fact we will miss out on the good things God has for us.

7. What is God calling you to change? ‘He who began a good work in you will carry it on to completion until the day of Christ Jesus’ (Phil 1.6)

For any Christian, the ultimate motive to make resolutions which will change our lives comes from what God is already doing in us. Change does not simply come through gritting our teeth and trying harder. Real change comes from being open to the work of change God wants to do in us by his Spirit.

I constantly find that the changes that stick and make a difference are the ones where I was convinced God was calling me to change and to grow. This has even been enough to make me leave the security of employment, up sticks and move to a different part of the country—on more than one occasion!

Perhaps resolving to listen to God for the change he wants to bring is the best resolution we can make.

(This article first appeared in Christian Today on 1st January 2016)

Follow me on Twitter @psephizo

Much of my work is done on a freelance basis. If you have valued this post, would you consider donating £1.20 a month to support the production of this blog?

Signup to get email updates of new posts
We promise not to spam you. Unsubscribe at any time.
Invalid email address

If you enjoyed this, do share it on social media (Facebook or Twitter) using the buttons on the left. Follow me on Twitter @psephizo. Like my page on Facebook.

Much of my work is done on a freelance basis. If you have valued this post, you can make a single or repeat donation through PayPal:

For other ways to support this ministry, visit my Support page.

Comments policy: Do engage with the subject. Please don't turn this into a private discussion board. Do challenge others in the debate; please don't attack them personally. I no longer allow anonymous comments; if there are very good reasons, you may publish under a pseudonym; otherwise please include your full name, both first and surnames.

2 thoughts on “Are resolutions the best way to change?”

  1. Hi Ian,

    Happy new year to you.

    These are some good tips. Although it does strike me that if you removed the Bible verses, points 1-6 would be at home in a secular blog as well… it wonder if you wrote the paragraphs before hunting for Bible verses to support them!

    I think ultimately New Year’s Resolutions don’t work because legalism doesn’t work: we can’t simply decide to be better people. We might be able to impose change on ourselves ‘from the outside’, so to speak,, but that is Pharisaism. We don’t want to become whitewashed tombs! We cannot change the heart by ourselves – we need God’s help. As we contemplate the finished work of Christ, through the power of the Holy Spirit we are able to change. As the Book of Common Prayer puts it after the 10 Commandments: “Lord, have mercy upon us, and write all these thy laws in our hearts, we beseech thee.”

    I particularly like the work of CCEF on this, e.g. “How People Change” by Lane and Tripp.

  2. Happy New Year Ian!

    I don’t quite understand the concept of January not being a “natural” time to change. Of course it is true that if you go on holiday in August you may have time to rethink your life. But otherwise what is particularly natural about changing in September? I find the quiet period between Christmas and New Year a good time to rethink. The most important thing about resolutions is of course, as many have said, be specific and measurable, and plan how to do it. “I will be more kind this year” is not going to work – “I am going to set aside the half hour drive to work to listen to the Bible on CD” might.


Leave a comment