Who is welcome in the people of God?

I write a column for Preach magazine, in which I explore a significant word or phrase in the Bible and the ideas that it expresses. The first one was on the phrase ‘Word of God’, and second on ‘Justice’, the third on ‘Mission’, the fourth on ‘Apocalypse‘, and the fifth on healing. This one, to be published in issue 25 (Winter 2020) explores the issue of welcome.


Who is welcome amongst the people of God? This is not just a theological question, but an eminently practical one. Who is welcome to attend and join with our church? On the one hand, we would not want anyone to feel unwelcome. But on the other, what happens when those of other faiths and none turn up? Does involvement make any demands, either in terms of belief or behaviour? What is the relationship between belonging and believing?

This is a question that the people of God have been wrestling with since they began to settle as a nation in the land that God had promised. In Joshua 2, the advanced party of spies encounter Rahab the prostitute, who on every count would surely be excluded from the promises and privileges of the people of God. Yet we find her treated in the New Testament as a model of faith (Heb 11.31) and an example of someone who, like Abraham, is considered righteous because of her actions demonstrating her trust in God (James 2.25). She is even rather awkwardly shoe-horned into the genealogy at the beginning of Matthew’s gospel (Matt1.5).

Once God’s people are settled in the land, very clear boundaries are put in place—not just in geo-political terms, defining the physical borders of the land, but in terms of belief and behaviour. Repeatedly we are told that the people of Israel are not to be like the nations that surround them, or the nations that dwelt in the land before them; their distinctiveness is part of their identity as the people of God (Deut 9.4, 18.9). Dwelling in the land brings both blessings and obligations, and you cannot have the one without the other.

It is surprising, then, that the question of ‘foreigners in your midst’ is addressed specifically, and primarily in terms of welcome. In a section of the law which is emphasising the distinct nature of their national life, the Israelites are commanded not merely to welcome foreigners, but to ‘treat them as native-born’; it is precisely such foreigners that are the ‘neighbours’ they are to ‘love as yourself’, since they knew what is was to be foreigners in Egypt. It is particularly the stranger and the outsider that God cares for (Ps 146.9), so those who are righteous will emulate this concern (Job 29.15), and Israel comes under judgment for failing to provide this radical welcome and care (Jer 7.5–7).

But there is something even more radical to this welcome. The prophets constantly point forward to God’s ultimate plan for his people and his world—and this plan includes foreigners, the alien and the strangers, finally incorporated into the renewed people of God, not as outsiders but as citizens (Ezek 47.22).


Perhaps, then, we should not be surprised to see this theme in the life and teaching of Jesus. In what is perhaps the most Jewish and ‘exclusive’ gospel, that according to Matthew, right at the beginning we find three other mothers mentioned alongside Rahab in the geneaology—Tamar, ‘the wife of Uriah’ (Bathsheba) and Ruth—and all four are foreigners and all four have dubious sexual associations.

This is the gospel that stresses, perhaps more than any other, the high standards of Jesus’ ethical teaching, and the demands of discipleship, but it also records Jesus as promising that  ‘many will come from the east and the west [that is, foreigners] and recline at table with Abraham, Isaac and Jacob in the kingdom of heaven’ (Matt 8.11). The tension between welcome and obligation is expressed most sharply in the parable of the king’s wedding feast in Matt 22.1–14. When those invited refuse the lavish feast that the king has prepared, he then invites anyone and everyone, ‘the bad and the good’ (verse 10) so that the wedding hall is ‘filled with guests’. And yet those who are welcomed need to take seriously their obligations—to leave their previous occupations, and be dressed appropriately (verse 11)—a cultural expectation that symbolises the change of life that comes from repentance and obedience.

Professor John Barclay summarises this tension by describing God’s grace as unconditioned, in that there is nothing we can do to merit it, but not as unconditional:

While there is no prior worth for receiving the gift, God indeed expects something in return. Paul expects those who receive the Spirit to be transformed by the Spirit and to walk in the Spirit. As he puts it, we are under grace, which can legitimately lead to obedience, even obligation.

We are to welcome all—not merely as passing guests, but with an invitation to full participation in the people of God, with all the blessings that that involves, alongside all the obligations.


If you enjoyed this, do share it on social media (Facebook or Twitter) using the buttons on the left. Follow me on Twitter @psephizo. Like my page on Facebook.


Much of my work is done on a freelance basis. If you have valued this post, you can make a single or repeat donation through PayPal:

For other ways to support this ministry, visit my Support page.


Comments policy: Good comments that engage with the content of the post, and share in respectful debate, can add real value. Seek first to understand, then to be understood. Make the most charitable construal of the views of others and seek to learn from their perspectives. Don't view debate as a conflict to win; address the argument rather than tackling the person.

10 thoughts on “Who is welcome in the people of God?”

  1. In Acts 5:12-14 we see the relationship of those outside the church to those in it.
    ESV
    “Now many signs and wonders were regularly done among the people by the hands of the apostles. And they were all together in Solomon’s Portico. None of the rest dared join them, but the people held them in high esteem. And more than ever believers were added to the Lord, multitudes of both men and women, …”

    People feel drawn to the believers by their holiness and drawn away from them by their sin. Yet God still ensures that according to his wishes they come to know him.

    The key thing I get from this is that people should feel both a sense that they are welcome and unwelcome only when the church is living in holiness. Note that there is no mention here of consciously welcoming people – nor of making a stand against specific behaviour. God is using the obedience of the saints to convict people of sin and draw them by his grace. It’s happening IN THE WORLD – not by unbelievers first joining the church.

    Reply
  2. Is Bathsheba a foreigner? I was not aware of that. Would that not rule her out of being Ahithophel’s grand-daughter since Ahithophel is from Judah?

    Reply
  3. Rahab,
    1) She trusted in Yahweh, Israel’s God, for rescue, for salvation, by God, through God’s judgement.
    “God saves us from God.” Dr John Piper.
    2) She married into one of the leading families in Israel, becoming part of the family line, part of matrinilial descent – tracing Jewish descent through the mother line) in Judaism. (The gospel of Matthew being particularly pertinent to Jewish people- some Messianic Jews have cited Matthew as being in highly instrumental in their acceptance of Jesus as Messiah.

    Reply
  4. I believe a distinction was made in the OT between two types of foreigners, ‘sojourners’ (nokrim or zarim) on one hand who were passing through or staying for a limited time, and on the other hand those who settled (gerim or toshav). There were greater expectations on those who settled, in terms of conforming with the life and laws of Israel, and they were both protected by Israel’s laws and bound by its responsibilities.

    Reply
  5. Valuable post, Ian. But Ruth has “dubious sexual connotations”? Her behaviour looks odd by modern standards, but it’s fairly explicitly praised in the text.

    Reply
  6. Perhaps we also need to note Exodus 12:38 the ‘many’ (Egyptians ?) who attached themselves to the Israelites. This positive note is presented negatively in Numbers where they are identified as ‘the rabble’.

    Reply
  7. Turning the tables: what about Christians being able to build churches in Arabia? Not in Saudi Arabia maybe, but in the Gulf States which are part of Arabia? Muslims regard themselves as the people of God – of El-ah (as in El-ohim, El-Shaddai, Emmanu-El, and Allah to all Arabic-speaking Christians). The Qur’an calls Christians ‘people of the book’. In Ian’s brief article ‘The Word of God’, he assumes the orthodox Christian view that Jesus is the final, Living Word of God.
    Ian asks two very different questions: ‘Who is welcome to attend our church’? and ‘Who is welcome to join our church’? While not all Muslims welcome Christians to attend prayers in their mosques, some do. When I on occasion attended mosque prayers, that did not of course draw me into ‘the house of Islam’; I would not identify myself in the prayer movements of the congregation, for all (I understand) they were probably learned from Christians. Muslim friends I hope understand that for me, Jesus died on the cross to pay the price of my sin, and broke death’s power over me, instead giving me Holy Spirit power to live for Him. And that I long that they will come to see that the Qur’an does not deny that Jesus died on the cross.

    Reply
    • Hi Ray,
      I have a little book ‘Ruhullah’ which points out all the verses in the Koran that contain the gospel. The cover has a quote from Surah 21:91 : “and (remember) her who guarded her chastity: We breathed into her of Our spirit, and We made her and her son a sign for all peoples.”

      Reply
      • Thanks Steve. I wonder if ‘Ruhullah’ lists the Qur’an verse: 4:157? While for 1,000 years Muslims have only interpreted the verse as denying the cross, maybe in the early days of Islam it was not necessarily read as denying the cross.

        Reply

Leave a comment