Gospel commentary index Lectionary Year A
On this page, you can find an index to all the commentary articles on the gospel lectionary readings for the whole of Year A, together with links to the video discussions between Ian and James. The articles will be reposted with updates during the year—but they are listed here for convenience and planning ahead.
The elephant in the nativity room?
John Hudghton writes: Around this time of year my nerdy mind turns to constructing an authentic biblical nativity scene. This amuses my family, to say the least. I try to take on board the lessons of biblical scholarship that Ian Paul has usefully and consistently emphasised for years now. Sadly, this is something which is usually lacking in commercially purchased nativity scenes or even those featured in many churches.
Surely, all readers of this blog must be familiar with the scene of Jesus born into a very modest Bethlehem dwelling. Constructed of fieldstone; mud mortar; a roof of timber; brush; more mud and perhaps embedded into a hillside, as were many homes in the vicinity. Not all had a guest room but the place where Jesus was born did, although for whatever reason (either already occupied or just too small) regarded as unsuitable for the birthing. We can probably assume that Jesus’ delivery either took place in the family room of a typical modest two main-roomed house, or in the lower level normally reserved for animals. These are the most common homes unearthed by the archaeological digs and analysis of these in Bethlehem. Bethlehem was known to be a poor agricultural community.
It is interesting to note that in first-century homes, the upper (living) area and the lower (stable) area were often separated by a stone wall. Set into this wall was a manger, designed so that it could be reached from both sides. Of course, the child born into the family was not ritually unclean, (even though the mother was) and a stone manger was probably advantageous too in this respect. The warmth of the animals would rise and help heat the living area. Such interior detail, familiar to the original audience, often omitted in a trite retelling of the birth narratives.
There was nothing unusual about this either, it was quite ordinary, although by today’s modern western standards we might consider it smelly and primitive. Let us remember though, that it was not that long ago in Britain that families still semi-shared their living spaces with their livestock.
Is John right about Jesus coming as judge in Matthew 3?
The lectionary gospel reading for Advent 2 in Year A is Matt 3.1–12, and it contains many foundational themes of eschatology, the coming of God, and judgement, which set us up nicely for thinking about Advent not as the build-up to Christmas, but (as it should be) thinking about the Last Things.
(You can see the video discussion of this passage here, and discussion of the epistle, Rom 15.4–13, here. Both are linked at the end of this article too.)
This is one of those passages where it is particularly informative to compare the gospel accounts side by side; you can do this with a printed text like Throckmorton’s Gospel Parallels, or online using something like this site from the University of Toronto. The online version is convenient, but the print edition highlights differences more clearly in its layout, as you can see here (click to enlarge). Just looking at the shape of the text, you can see the different emphases in the three Synoptic accounts.
We can see immediately the different interests of the gospel writers. Luke locates the beginning of John’s ministry in the larger world of the Roman empire, whilst the Fourth Gospel doesn’t explain either John’s ministry or Jesus’ baptism, but assumes you already know about it from reading the other gospels. There is an interesting contrast between Matthew and Mark’s ordering of elements (which I am not sure commentaries pick up) which is striking since, in other respects, Matthew follows Mark quite closely. Mark introduces John the Baptiser in this order:
OT prophecy—John’s preaching (and baptism)—the people’s response—John’s appearance
but Matthew introduces the elements in this order:
John’s preaching—OT prophecy—John’s appearance—the people’s response (and baptism)
Unity between Jew and Gentile in Rom 15 video discussion
The epistle for Advent 2 in this Year A is Rom 15.4–13. It follows on from Paul’s discussion about the ‘strong’ and the ‘weak’ in chapter 14, and in many…
The nature of doctrine, marriage, and discipline in the C of E
Martin Davie writes: Three papers have recently been published by the Church of England’s Faith and Order Commission to provide advice to the House of Bishops and the General Synod…
Why is the Exodus important for the New Testament?
I write a quarterly column for Preach magazine, in which I explore a significant word, phrase, or idea in the Bible, or a theme or section of Scripture, and the…
Why you should want to be ‘left behind’ in Matthew 24!
With the advent of Advent on Sunday, we make the move in the lectionary from Year C to Year A. So, after journeying through Luke all year, this Sunday’s gospel…
Why is the Book of Revelation claimed by every era?
One of the (many) great paradoxes of the Book of Revelation is that, at one and the same time, it is experienced as both very difficult to interpret, yet also…
Can the PLF process be rescued?
Andrew Goddard writes: The recent announcement from the House of Bishops (discussed here by me and here by Ian Paul) is raising the question as to how it relates to…
How should we see Christ as King in Luke 23?
This Sunday was traditionally known in the Church of England as ‘Stir-up Sunday‘, a phrase derived from the BCP Collect for the last Sunday before Advent, which in turn inspired…
Can the BBC be re-enchanted?
David Campanale writes: It was in a one-to-one union meeting with BBC management where I met the darkness. In the wake of the post-Jimmy Savile BBC Trust investigation into a…
Once again: Jesus was not born in a stable!
Every year, in the northern hemisphere, and especially in Northern Europe, we are apparently caught by surprise as the evenings draw in, and the morning light comes later. It always…

























